Sign up for our Headlines morning newsletter.

The most interesting things on the web, handpicked each day. Sign up for our Headlines morning newsletter.

Writing About Writers

Birds Without Wings

Those lefties are at it again in Paul Berman's new tome.

Book Cover There may be a tendency to dismiss intra-left political conflicts with a version of the old saw about literary squabbles—that is, the reason they are so impassioned and contentious is they argue about so little. Though there are jokes to be made about the apparent self-destructiveness of the Left (I am baffled as to why we still rely on an antiquated political taxonomy), there are real-world consequences of left doctrinal and philosophical slugfests.

Paul Berman (Terror and Liberalism), whom I admired back during the Reagan Follies for his sympathetic stand on Nicaragua’s plight during its assault by the usual claque of American imperialist cowboys, has, like Christopher Hitchens, complicated his identity and baffled longstanding admirers by supporting the Iraq Disaster and is now, based on his new manifesto, The Flight of the Intellectuals (Melville House), once more engaged in rhetorical fisticuffs with other so-called liberal intellectuals (a label that in the popular culture no doubt discredits the whole pack of them). This to-and-fro is, as far as I can tell, well documented in what seems to be the still-existent New York Observer.

Involving such formidable writers and thinkers such as Tony Judt, Ian Buruma, and Mark Lilla, the gloves are apparently off when you read Buruma unflatteringly describing Berman: “He gets very emotional. He gets very excited… a lot of spittle around the mouth and so on. You don’t really need that.”

The crux of Paul Berman’s concern (first aired in his New Republic response to Ian Buruma’s New York Times Magazine profile of influential Swiss-born Egyptian scholar and devout Muslim and Oxford professor Tariq Ramadan) is the fact that Ramadan happens to be the Muslim Brotherhood founder Hassan al-Banna’s grandson. Berman contends that though there are a host of eloquent critics of Islamic fundamentalism/extremism, Tariq Ramadan is not to be trusted and in fact may be the proverbial wolf in sheep’s clothing.

You can also follow some of this brouhaha in Dwight Garner’s review, which concludes:
There’s a good deal of inside baseball.… Scores are settled that many readers won’t know or care about. But this bracing and volatile book is an important one and devastating in its conclusions about the secret history of some Islamists and especially about the reception of Ayaan Hirsi Ali. “It was obvious that Hirsi Ali had received a dreadful treatment from journalists,” Mr. Berman writes, “who ought to have known better.
blog comments powered by Disqus