Now comes Harvard mentor and writer Leo Damrosch (Jean-Jacques Rousseau: Restless Genius) with Tocqueville’s Discovery of America (FSG), a concise revaluation including previously un-translated documents and exhibiting fastidious scholarship. Princeton historian Sean Willentz assesses:
Helping to humanize as well as historicize the young Tocqueville while he was discovering America is the main achievement of Damrosch’s concise and absorbing new book [It] ought to make a more nuanced appreciation of both the man and his great work accessible to a wide readership The human young Tocqueville is much more impressive than the cold abstraction, and for helping to bring him to life we are in Leo Damrosch’s debt.It is worth quoting Damrosch for some context:
Theirs was hardly the most exotic journey of the erain December of the same year, the 22-year-old Charles Darwin set sail in the Beagle, at a moment when Tocqueville and Beaumont were relaxing on a Mississippi steamboatbut in the context of French culture and politics it was exotic enough. At a deep level, in fact, there was a real similarity between Tocqueville and Darwin. Unlike superficial travelers, they both wrote compellingly because they were so keenly observantDarwin of the natural world with glances at society, and Tocqueville of society, with glances at nature. And if he was discovering America, Tocqueville had the exceptional insight to grasp the nation was engaged in ongoing self-discovery.One reviewer concludes:
Damrosch is an acute observer of Tocqueville, whose generalizations, he notes, don’t always stand up to scrutiny. Although Tocqueville was right about the importance of America’s middle class, he minimized widening divisions between the rich and the poor. Tocqueville took an overly harsh view of Andrew Jackson, dismissing him as a man of violent temperament and mediocre abilities, ignoring his charisma and his political abilities. An agnostic raised as a Catholic, Tocqueville exaggerated the oddness of evangelical religion, misreading its social meaning for Americans.
Still, as Damrosch suggests, Tocqueville’s responses to America were more perceptive and appreciative than those of other European travelers, like Frances Trollope and Charles Dickens.